As a small business owner seeking financing, you should be aware of recent developments in lending regulations. The CFPB Small Business Lending Rule, designed to promote fair lending practices, has been upheld in court despite significant challenges from the financial industry. Here's what you need to know about the rule and the recent legal battle.
The Legal Challenge Explained:
The United States District Court for the Southern District of Texas issued a decision upholding the legality of the CFPB Small Business Lending Rule designed to implement section 1071 of the Dodd-Frank Act in a lawsuit filed by plaintiff trade associations challenging the CFPB’s authority in promulgating the Rule:
1. Questioning CFPB's Authority:
· Claim: The rule doesn't advance fair lending enforcement or identify needs of women and minority-owned businesses.
· Court's Response: Rejected this argument, stating it attacked the rule's effectiveness, not its purpose.
2. Arbitrary and Capricious Implementation:
· Claim: CFPB didn't adequately consider costs to lenders and customers.
· Court's Response: Disagreed, noting CFPB's detailed cost-benefit analysis.
Additional Challenge:
Trade associations argued CFPB can't require reporting of data not typically collected.
Court found this contradicted by the statute's text.
What This Means for Your Small Business Loan Application:
1. More Detailed Data Collection:
· Lenders will ask about your race, ethnicity, and gender
· Geographic information and credit decisions will be recorded
2. First Comprehensive Database:
· Creates a national picture of small business lending practices
3. Potential Benefits:
· May lead to fairer lending practices
· Could identify underserved markets
4. Possible Short-Term Effects:
· Loan applications might take longer as lenders adapt
· More questions during the application process
While the court has upheld the rule, the legal battle isn't over. The judge delayed final judgment to consider additional motions. However, small business owners should prepare for these changes, as they're likely to be implemented.
What You Can Do:
1. Stay informed about the rule's implementation timeline
2. Be prepared to provide more detailed information when applying
3. Understand your rights regarding fair lending practices
Remember, this rule aims to create a more equitable lending environment for all small businesses, particularly those owned by women, minorities, and those in rural areas. While it may involve more paperwork in the short term, the long-term goal is to ensure fair access to credit for all entrepreneurs.
As you plan your business financing strategy, keep these upcoming changes in mind. The additional data collected could ultimately lead to better-tailored financial products and services for small businesses like yours.
Consult with an L&F Brown Attorney
Should you have any questions or concerns about the Legal Issues addressed in this blog post, please reach out to Derek Saunders, Keith Strahan, or Richard Armstrong of our firm, shown here: https://lfbrown.law/our-team
Comments